I bought one for my Xbox 360. I like it but it doesn't make regular DVD's look any better in my opinion. I am using an LCD HD TV 42inch JVC. The HDDVD picture is awesome but the player is temperamental and won't play the DVD if it is in any way dirty. Do you need one.. probably not, but did you really need an Xbox either? It's not about what you need but what you want. So if you want it and can afford it I say buy it.
